HardwareLogic
Welcome Guest. Please register or log in now. There are 19 people online (0 Friends).
  • Home
  • Articles
  • News
  • Forum
  • New Forum
  • UCP
  • Shop@HL
You are at HardwareLogic » Articles » Reviews Index » Noctua 80mm and 120mm Case Fans

Noctua 80mm and 120mm Case Fans

Author
The HL Staff
Editor
Aron Schatz
Posted
October 17, 2007
Views
1149
Noctua 80mm and 120mm Case Fans
When you think of case fans, a lot of names come to mind, but unless you're a cooling connoisseur that's traversed all corners of the web, Noctua probably isn't one of them. That's where we at HardwareLogic come in, bravely venturing the web where few geeks have gone before, and in our latest wanderings, we've stumbled upon an Austrian company dedicated to a small array of cooling products.
Tags Technology

Page 1:



When you think of case fans, a lot of names come to mind, but unless you're a cooling connoisseur that's traversed all corners of the web, Noctua probably isn't one of them.  That's where we at HardwareLogic come in, bravely venturing the web where few geeks have gone before, and in our latest wanderings, we've stumbled upon an Austrian company dedicated to a small array of cooling products.

What Does Noctua Mean?
The little owl, Athene noctua, is the symbol of the Greek goddess Athene, who represents wisdom, science and strategy. She has a marked preference for the most clever among the Greek heroes, like Odysseus, who endure their adventures by the use of savvy consideration instead of mere force. Until today, the owl symbolises intelligence and prudence, its manlike face emblematises attentiveness and communication. We from Noctua follow the suit of its calm and accurate observation in the dark, its soundless flight as well as the effective, economical use of its powers and precise attack. - Noctua

Alrighty then! So just what kind of 'precise attack' can we expect from a pair of bling-less fans designed by the little owl that could?  Noctua claims they designed their fans with a sound optimized geometry and profile that promise to be the quietest around this side of the Pecos.  Will they live up to their hushed billing, or are the claims full of hot air?

Specifications

 Size 80mm and 120mm
 RPM 800-1800 (80mm) / 1200 (120mm)
 Type Oil pressure bearing
 Noise 7dBA (80mm) / <6dBA (120mm) 
 Warranty
 6 years


As you can see Noctua has chosen to go with the brown/creme color combo for their fans. For those of you who are into the bright lights and matching the right color for your rig, you might want to pass on these. It is very apparent that these fans are not going to have the Fatal1ty logo on them any time soon, which, quite frankly, earns bonus points in our book.


For our review, we chose to put these fans in our HTPC Thermaltake Tenor case, replacing the noisy 80mm and two 60mm fans that currently reside inside.  By doing so, we hoped to rid our system of the jet engine sound that's plagued our ears, but when it came time for installation, we ran into a bit of a snag.


Call it poor planning on our part, or just plain stubborn insistence, but the Tenor case lacks a 120mm fan mount.  But hey, it's for situations like these that zip ties were created, and with a little fiddling and some wire rearrangement, we were successful in replacing the three old fans with the Noctua variety.

With an HTPC equipped with 4 total fans going, it is not hard realize that something is missing.  That something missing was the Boeing 747 underneath our Plasma.  By replacing the aforementioned fans with that of the 2 Noctua fans, there was a very discernible, if not dramatic difference in sound output.  But how did it do with cooling?

To measure temperatures inside the enclosure, we used SpeedFan.  Our testing consisted of the closed enclosure with the three original fans, taking a temperature reading at startup.  The speed of the fans was controlled by checking the auto control box in SpeedFan itself.  We then retook temp readings after watching a movie (Talladega Nights, because you're curious).  We then let the let the computer sit powered down for a day and started it up fresh for our next round of tests with the Noctua fans installed.  The testing consisted of the same criteria as the other fans.

 Thermaltake Startup
Noctua Startup
Thermaltake Shutdown
Noctua Shutdown 
CPU 48
48
48 48 
Case49
49
49
49
HDD 25
25
35
26

As you can see there isn’t much difference in temperatures for any of the tests, which we ultimately blame on the Tenor's ventilation acting as a bottleneck.  But what's of real note here is that the Noctua fans didn't have an adverse effect on cooling in a cramped HTPC environment, while also managing to substantially reduce noise levels.  In other words, noise management gurus concerned with cooling trade offs can have their cake and eat it too.



Warranty and Support

Noctua offers a generous 6-year warranty on all of their fans.  Their support page includes a Direct-RMA form, online FAQ, and a  contact email address.  Note that for RMA service, you will need to retail a copy of your sales invoice, and upload a scanned copy when filling out the RMA form (boo!).

Our Recommendation

There's no doubt about it; the Noctua fans do a premium job at controlling airflow while maintaining low noise levels, while also carrying a premium price tag.  If you can get over the sticker shock, there's a lot to like here, including a lengthy 6-year warranty.

What the Noctua fans don't have are flashing LEDs, Fatal1ty logos, or other gamer oriented bling, and you have to be resigned to the fact that the brown and crème color scheme is the only flavor offered.  Aesthetics aside, these fans come with a pretty good bundle, giving you both 4-pin connectors and 3-pin extension connectors, and rubber standoffs to help with vibration and further manage noise control. If function over form is your game, you will have a hard time finding a fan that performs as well as these Noctua units do at such low noise levels. Just be prepared to pay for the cooling extravagance, which can reach upwards of $20/ea street.

Other Reviews of Note

It's always nice to have more than one opinion on a component before you spend your hard earned money. For one, we may see something others missed, or vice versa. As with all reviews published at HardwareLogic, we'll not only give you our recommendation, but also point out some reviews from some other great sites from around the web.
DarkVision Hardware
BigBruin
 
Page 1
View As Single Page Print This Page Print Entire Article
Related Articles
  • Kingston 128GB V Series SSD
  • Crucial M225 128GB SSD
  • Cooler Master Storm Sentinel Advance Mouse
  • Plextor PX-B320SA 8X Blu-ray Combo Drive
  • Seagate BlackArmor NAS 220
images/siteimages/upload/2009/10/18/3258o2d.jpg 1316

Title

Medium Image View Large
Login
Welcome Guest. Please register or log in now.
Forgot your password?
Advertisement
Latest News
  • The PS3 has been hacked, but probably not the way you might have expected.
  • iPhone Users: US Government says it's Legal to Jailbreak Now
  • Samsung Galaxy S Launch Event
  • Steam For Mac Released, Linux Support On The Way
  • New Malware Uses Bogus Copyright Infringement Alerts
  • Novel wins SCO Unix case (that started 7 years ago)
  • Upcoming PS3 Firmware to Remove System Features
  • World's Smallest Laser
  • TV History from Popular Science Articles
  • Kernel Vulnerabilities Discovered in Ubuntu/Kubuntu/Edubuntu/Xubuntu
Latest Articles
  • Antec Dark Fleet DF-85 Enthusiast Gaming Case
  • Crucial RealSSD C300 256GB CTFDDAC256MAG-1G1
  • Sharkoon Silent Eagle SE 120mm & 80mm Fans
  • Thermaltake Armor A90 VL90001W2Z
  • Thermaltake Frio CLP0564
  • Thermaltake V3 Black Edition VL80001W2Z
  • Antec Fusion Remote Black
  • Kingston SSDNow V Series 30GB SNV125-S2BD/30GB
  • Imation M-Class 128GB SSD
  • Kingston SSDNow V+ Series 128GB SNVP325-S2B/128GB
Advertisement
Affiliate Reviews
  • Ubuntu 10.10 "Maverick Meerkat" Beta Released at Phoronix
  • Toshiba Folio 100 tablet finally becomes official at Hexus
  • AMD justifies decision to drop ATI brand at Hexus
  • ASUS announces partnership with AMIMON at Hexus
  • PlayStation Plus content detailed for coming months at Hexus
  • Microsoft searches for partner to boost its China Bing share at Hexus
  • Europe has to wait for major Kinect feature until Spring 2011 at Hexus
  • ‘Frustrated’ consumers want broadband advertising overhaul at Hexus
  • openSUSE 11.4 Milestone 1 Released at Phoronix
  • MSI aims for 1GHz with GTX 460 Hawk at Hexus
  • Who Contributed The Most During X Server 1.9? at Phoronix
  • Trio of "big surprises" from Valve in the next 12 months at Hexus
  • IE6 finally starts to fade away at Hexus
  • Windows Phone 7 released to manufacturing, October launch? at Hexus
Press Release
  • National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) Responds to FCC Public Notice Announcement
  • Alliance for Digital Equality Statement on Federal Communications Commission Plan to Move Forward in Alignment with National Broadband Plan
  • UBM TechWeb's HDI Launches the HDI Desktop Support Manager Certification Program; Three-Day Course to Be Offered Across the United States Beginning in November
  • Synopsys Completes Acquisition of Virage Logic Corporation
  • 3ality Digital to Capture First NFL Game to Air on S3D TV
  • New I/O Modules Provide Two CAN Bus Interface Channels for Industrial PCs and Embedded Systems
  • Consumer Watchdog Takes 'Do Not Track Me' Campaign to Times Square With Animated Video Targeting Google CEO's Lack of Respect for Privacy
  • Verizon Wireless 'Tackles' Heavy Cell Phone Usage at The Big House by Boosting 3G Capacity
  • Focus.com Launches New Interactive Summits; Announces Fall Schedule
  • FastPencil Launches FastPencil Premiere Imprint Designed Specifically for Top-Tier Authors
© 2010 Aron Schatz (ASE Publishing) [Queries: 14 (7 Cached)] [Rows: 201 Fetched: 9] [Page Generation time: 0.065579175949097]